The girls we're considering

Donors

fresh donors on our short list — ranked for Michelle, with each one's photos

What this page is: the fresh donors we’re actively considering — the ones Michelle likes — each read in full, scored for resemblance to Michelle, and cross-matched against Rob’s genetics. New girls get added here as you find them.

Michelle’s reference profile (the basis for resemblance):

Light-brown hairBlue eyesFair complexionLonger / oval faceLean, athletic, petiteGymnastEnglish + Polish
🆕 New this search round — Aug 22, 2026: added Donor 4795, 4655, and 4688 to the list below (look for the pink New tags). Also new — a Frozen: Available Right Away shortlist (MyEggBank + Fairfax, eggs ready to ship now) is on the Bank Donors page.

⭐ New picks · Aug 25

🆕 New this round — Aug 25, 2026. Two fresh profiles, rated in full against Michelle below. Donor 4742 is now out (genetics & timeline stalled; deposit is refundable), so these are the new focus. 4458 is Rob’s #1 to evaluate; 4441 is here too because she actually scores highest on resemblance. The earlier seven are kept as secondary further down.
Scoring against Michelle: light-brown hair · blue eyes · fair · oval face · lean / athletic / petite · English + Polish.
Donor 4458
Rob’s #1 pick

Donor 4458

Donor Nexus · b.1995 (~30) · 5’6″, 125 lb · brown wavy hair · hazel eyes · olive complexion · O− · Scottish/Swedish/German + English/French/German · Business Communication, cum laude · gym 5–6×/wk, motorcycle, scuba, tennis.
Resemblance
80
/ 100 to Michelle
Coloring66
Face82
Build / athletic84
Ancestry88
Genetics vs Rob (OCA4/SLC45A2): Horizon 275-gene panel flags one carrier condition — Smith-Lemli-Opitz — and not OCA4/SLC45A2, so she looks clear against Rob. Confirm SLC45A2 was on her panel, and that Rob isn’t also an SLOS carrier (his Invitae positive was only OCA4).
Fertility: Elite — the most proven donor we’ve seen. Five egg-banking cycles: 22 · 24 (18 frozen) · 24 (16 frozen) · 32 (24 frozen) · and a full workup last cycle: 23 eggs → 14 mature → 14 fertilized → 11 biopsied → 9 genetically-normal embryos.

Read for Michelle: The proven powerhouse, and the cleaner genetics of the two. The one honest gap is coloring — she’s olive-skinned with hazel eyes and darker hair, where Michelle is fair and blue-eyed. Face, athletic build and Northern-European ancestry all read close. If proven fertility and a clean carrier panel lead your priorities, she’s the strongest candidate on the whole list.

🔗 View Donor 4458 on Donor Nexus →
Donor 4441
New · highest resemblance

Donor 4441

Donor Nexus · b.1995 (~30) · 5’2″, 117 lb · blonde hair · blue eyes · fair (Nordic) · A+ · Swedish / Norwegian / Swiss · AMH 3.06 · model & marketing · soccer, tennis, volleyball, painter.
Resemblance
89
/ 100 to Michelle
Coloring94
Face86
Build / athletic91
Ancestry82
Genetics vs Rob (OCA4/SLC45A2): Horizon 568-gene panel flags four carriers — Alpha-1 Antitrypsin, Cystic Fibrosis, Gitelman, McKusick-Kaufman — but not OCA4/SLC45A2, so she also looks clear against Rob. None overlap his OCA4; still, it’s more to confirm than 4458’s single flag — check Rob is negative for those four, especially CF.
Fertility: Proven, strong reserve. Cycle 1: 15 eggs → 10 mature → 10 fertilized → 6 biopsied → 6 normal embryos; Cycle 2: 18 eggs. AMH 3.06 ng/mL. (Family note: her father had a stroke at 58.)

Read for Michelle: The closest look to Michelle — fair, blue-eyed, petite and Nordic, matching Michelle’s actual coloring and frame better than anyone on the list, which is why her resemblance score is the highest here. She’s proven too. The trade-offs vs 4458: a busier carrier panel (four vs one) and a slightly lighter fertility record. On looks alone, she’s the top match.

🔗 View Donor 4441 on Donor Nexus →
Bottom line, straight: both are strong and both look genetically clear against Rob’s OCA4. 4458 (Rob’s pick) wins on proven fertility and the cleaner carrier panel; 4441 wins on resemblance to Michelle. It’s a proven-track-record vs closest-look call — not a quality gap.

Secondary · the earlier seven

This round’s list — newest first

DonorScoreIn one line
New479581Blonde/blue/light, lifelong athlete; ~18, no AMH, unproven, unscreened, ancestry only “Caucasian.”
New465580Petite 5’4″, proven, athletic; Danish/Italian + ~20% Jewish (expanded panel); AMH TBD.
New468879Very fair blonde/blue, oval face; proven (23 eggs) + already OCA4-clear; tall 5’9″, Turkish, international.
—470584Polish both sides, blonde/blue/fair, AMH 5.61; fuller face vs oval, unproven, genetics pending.
⛔474283OUT (Aug 25) — genetics & timeline stalled; deposit refundable. Blue/fair/English, athletic & petite.
—428580Fair blonde, AMH 7.63, young; hazel eyes, Brazilian/Italian.
⭐445880Promoted — now Rob’s #1. Full rating in New picks · Aug 25 above. Proven high-responder (9 normal embryos last cycle), OCA4-clear; olive skin + hazel eyes.
Specialist read: 4742 is now out (Aug 25) (deposit paid, carrier screening underway) — everyone else here is the bench in case we ever need it. On the bench: 4705 is still the top look on paper (Polish both sides, blonde/blue/fair). Among the three new adds, 4795 is the best coloring-plus-athletic match but is very young and totally unscreened/unproven; 4655 is the best build match (petite, proven) with a Jewish-ancestry panel caveat; and 4688 is the safest on results of the new three — proven and already OCA4-clear — but she’s tall, Turkish, and overseas.
⚠️ Genetics: five of the seven still need screening

Fresh donors are usually screened after you match. 4742 (our match) is being screened now by IVFMD; 4705, 4795, 4285 and 4655 have not been screened — their OCA4/SLC45A2 status is unknown until run. 4655 is ~20% Jewish, so her panel should be the expanded (Ashkenazi) one. Two are already screened and OCA4-clear: 4458 (Horizon 275; carries DHCR7) and 4688 (Horizon 568; carries SRNS). Neither overlaps Rob’s OCA4.

Full profiles & photos

The Seven, In Depth

🆕 New this round · Aug 22

The Newest Three

NEW
Donor 4795 New · Aug 22Donor Nexus · ~18 · Caucasian (American) · California
81Resembl.
Today
Portrait
At the beach
As a child

🔗 View Donor 4795 on Donor Nexus →

Physical

Height: 5’6″ · Weight: 130 lb · Eyes: Blue · Hair: Blonde · Complexion: Light · No glasses · Right-handed. Small birthmark on forehead.

Ancestry

Caucasian / White on both sides — no specific heritage listed and no heritage testing done, so English/Polish can’t be confirmed. Born in California.

Education & work

Nursing student (in progress, GPA 3.8) — scholar-athlete, top of class, multiple basketball awards. Works as a server; goal is EMT → forensic nurse.

Personality (her words)

“I’m a very outgoing, hardworking, independent woman — loud, funny, and super friendly. I love being around people, and I’m a very outdoorsy, adventurous person.”

Talents & interests

Lifelong athlete — basketball (awarded), works out several times a week; raised animals for FFA. Outdoorsy and adventurous.

Fertility

No fertility testing yet — no AMH on file and she has never donated (first-time). Very young (~18). Regular cycles; IUD in place ~6 months; never pregnant.

Family (physical) & health

Her own: emergency appendectomy (while traveling). No known genetic conditions or birth defects reported in the family; not of Jewish ancestry.

Genetics

Carrier screening not done yet — OCA4/SLC45A2 status unknown until run.

Specialist read: the strongest coloring-and-athletic match of the three new adds — blonde, blue, light, 5’6″, and a genuine lifelong athlete whose sporty streak echoes Michelle’s gymnast background. The honest caveats are real, though: she’s very young (~18), has no fertility testing or AMH and has never donated, and her ancestry is only listed as generic “Caucasian.” Genetics still need running.
NEW
Donor 4655 New · Aug 22Donor Nexus · ~26 · Danish / Italian (~20% Jewish) · Canada
80Resembl.
Today
Portrait
Full length
As a child

🔗 View Donor 4655 on Donor Nexus →

Physical

Height: 5’4″ · Weight: 135 lb · Eyes: Blue · Hair: Blonde, wavy · Complexion: Fair · Blood: O− · Right-handed.

Ancestry

Maternal Danish; 23andMe shows Danish, Italian, and ~19.7% Jewish. Born in Canada. The Danish side is a Northern-European match to Michelle; Italian and Jewish are the softer differences.

Education & work

Bachelor’s in Interior Design (always honors); skipped a grade and graduated high school at 16. Works in interior design & sales; bought her first property.

Personality (her words)

“Outgoing, smart, genuine.” Helping someone build a family is “one of the most meaningful gifts you can ever give.”

Talents & interests

Very athletic — slowpitch, boxing, surfing, and the gym 5×/week.

Fertility

Proven donor (prior donation cycle) · fertility testing done, though AMH is not listed on her profile — confirm with the agency. Regular ~4-week cycles; never pregnant.

Family (physical) & health

No significant illnesses or surgeries; no known genetic conditions or birth defects reported in the family. She is ~19.7% Jewish (see genetics).

Genetics

Carrier screening not confirmed on file — OCA4/SLC45A2 status unknown. Because she is ~20% Jewish, her panel should be the expanded (Ashkenazi) screen (Tay-Sachs, etc.), which is not yet done.

Specialist read: the best build match of the new three — petite 5’4″, fair, blonde, blue, athletic, and a proven donor. Her Danish heritage lines up with Michelle’s Northern-European side. Two watch-items: her AMH isn’t listed (confirm it), and her Jewish ancestry means the carrier panel should be the expanded one and cross-matched carefully.
NEW
Donor 4688 New · Aug 22Donor Nexus · ~27 · Turkish · France (international)
79Resembl.
Today
On the court
Outdoors
As a child

🔗 View Donor 4688 on Donor Nexus →

Physical

Height: 5’9″ · Weight: 119 lb · Eyes: Blue · Hair: Blonde, straight · Complexion: Fair · Blood: O+ · Right-handed. Small mole below one eyebrow.

Ancestry

Turkish on both sides — born in Istanbul, holds French residency. A clear difference from Michelle’s English/Polish, though her coloring reads very Northern-European.

Education & work

Bachelor’s degree + Graphic Design (2020). Freelance graphic designer; former Emirates flight attendant.

Personality (her words)

“Good listener, positive, solution-oriented, adaptable, social, animal lover.” On donating: “I like the idea of helping someone who wants a family but can’t do it on their own… I take it seriously.”

Talents & interests

Athletic — tennis and padel, gym 4–5×/week, painting, psychology reading. Was “the fastest runner in school.”

Fertility

AMH 2.88 ng/mL (lower-normal, similar to 4742) · Proven — one cycle produced 23 eggs, 19 mature. A strong real-world result.

Family (physical) & health

No allergies, medications, illnesses, or surgeries reported.

Genetics

Screened — Horizon 568 · Carrier of SRNS (Steroid-Resistant Nephrotic Syndrome); negative for the other 567 including SLC45A2. Not an OCA4 carrier — OCA4-clear. Doesn’t overlap Rob’s gene; just confirm Rob is negative for SRNS (he was negative for everything except OCA4).

Specialist read: a striking coloring match — very fair, blonde, blue-eyed, long oval face — and the safest of the new three on results: proven (23 eggs) and already OCA4-clear. The real trade-offs are that she’s tall (5’9″) vs. Michelle’s petite frame, her ancestry is Turkish (not English/Polish), and she’s international (France/Turkey) — which adds travel, cost, and immigration logistics.

Earlier picks · already reviewed

The Original Four

1
Donor 4705Journey group · ~25 · Polish (both sides) · Pennsylvania
84Resembl.
Today
As a child

🔗 View Donor 4705 on Donor Nexus →

Physical

Height: 5’6″ · Weight: 128 lb · Eyes: Blue · Hair: Blonde · Complexion: Fair · Blood: B+ · No glasses.

Ancestry

Polish on both sides — the closest heritage match on the whole list. Directly matches Michelle’s Polish side; both parents Polish. Caucasian.

Education & work

Bachelor’s in Finance & Accounting, GPA 4.0 (Kozminski University, Warsaw). Currently nannying on a gap year, then moving into sales. Paints; acted when younger.

Personality (her words)

“Open, empathetic, and energetic, with a friendly, approachable nature… friends describe me as calm and reassuring — they feel safe and supported around me. Loyalty, honesty and helpfulness are non-negotiable.”

On donating: “a unique opportunity to help someone achieve their dream of becoming a parent.”

Talents & interests

Very athletic — yoga almost daily, gym regularly, hiking, boxing & Muay Thai, tennis, skiing in winter. Loves painting, psychology, reading, and travel; drawn to meeting people from other cultures. Grew up in a small city next to Warsaw.

Fertility

AMH 5.61 ng/mL — a strong ovarian-reserve number. Regular cycles; never donated before (so not yet proven by a cycle).

Family (physical) & health

Father 5’11″ brown/brown, IT director; mother 5’6″ green/blonde, HR; grandparents run tall and fair (several blonde/blue). A younger sister (18, artistic) and brother (10). Family health is notably clean — the only flag across three generations is high blood pressure / heart in the maternal grandfather (passed at 77). No cancer, no genetic conditions, no psychiatric history reported.

Genetics

Carrier screening not done yet — no panel on file. OCA4/SLC45A2 status unknown until a full panel (Horizon/Foresight) is run and cross-checked with Rob. This is her main open item.

Specialist read: on heritage and coloring she’s the best match on the list — Polish both sides, blonde, blue-eyed, fair, athletic, with a healthy AMH and a very clean family history. Her childhood photo (golden hair, blue eyes, round cheeks) is a tender echo of Michelle’s. Two honest caveats: her adult face reads a little fuller/rounder than Michelle’s longer oval and her recent photos are heavily filtered (the childhood shot is the truer likeness), and she’s never donated, so the AMH is promising but unproven. Genetics still need running.
2
Donor 4742  ⛔ Out · Aug 25Donor Nexus · ~31 · English (both sides) · Arkansas
83Resembl.
Today
Full length
At the gym
As a child

🔗 View Donor 4742 on Donor Nexus →

Physical

Height: 5’4″ · Weight: 135 lb · Eyes: Blue (wears glasses) · Hair: Brown · Complexion: Light / fair · Hand: Right.

Ancestry

English on both sides — a very close ancestry match to Michelle’s English/Polish. Born in Arkansas.

Education & work

B.S. in Health & Exercise Science (GPA 3.5); works as an egg-donor care coordinator and fitness trainer.

Personality (her words)

“I’m extremely kind and bubbly… I love to stick up for people. I wear my heart on my sleeve… I grew up extremely close with my family — they are my world.”

On donating: “I’ve always wanted children… I know how much I crave to be a mom, so I can only imagine how someone ready for children must feel… It gives me butterflies thinking about being part of that journey for someone else.”

Talents & interests

Fitness professional — works out daily, runs, walks; degree in exercise science; loves crafts, self-help books, and her toy poodle Theodore. Favorite colors pink & yellow; favorite film Save the Last Dance.

Fertility

AMH 2.60 ng/mL — on the lower-normal side, worth noting; but she is a proven donor (2 prior cycles: 19 and 26 eggs). Regular cycles; never pregnant.

Family (physical) & health

Mother 5’1″ green eyes/brown hair; father 6’2″ brown eyes/blonde hair; two older brothers, one younger sister (blonde, blue eyes). Health flags: father heart attack at 53; high blood pressure in three grandparents; type-2 diabetes in one grandmother. No family cancer or mental-health history. Her own: breast augmentation (2024); an HPV pap that resolved on its own.

Genetics

Carrier screening not done yet — OCA4/SLC45A2 status unknown until IVFMD runs the panel.

Specialist read: a very strong resemblance — blue eyes, fair, English, athletic, petite (5’4″), with the more oval face. Two honest things to weigh: her AMH (2.60) is lower (her real-world cycles were still strong, so it’s a question for IVFMD, not a stop sign), and there’s a cardiac note (dad’s heart attack at 53). Genetics still need running.
3
Donor 4285Donor Nexus · ~26 · Italian & Portuguese (born Brazil) · New Jersey
80Resembl.
Today
Portrait
With her horse
As a child

🔗 View Donor 4285 on Donor Nexus →

Physical

Height: 5’5″ · Weight: 135 lb · Eyes: Hazel · Hair: Blonde, wavy · Complexion: Fair · Blood: A+ · Hand: Right.

Ancestry

Multi-racial, born in Brazil; maternal Italian, paternal Portuguese.

Education & work

High school (B+); waitress; former teacher’s assistant.

Personality (her words)

“I’m a caring and empathetic person who forgives easily. I work hard, stay organized, and approach life with a cheerful and happy attitude.”

Talents & interests

Cooking, traveling, time with family; horseback riding in photos. Favorite film 13 Going on 30.

Fertility

AMH 7.63 ng/mL — a strong ovarian-reserve number. Age ~26, regular cycles; never pregnant, no prior donation.

Family (physical) & health

Mother 5’3″ hazel/brown; father 5’10″ green/blonde; a twin brother and a younger brother (blonde). Family health is remarkably clean — every category answered “none.” Her own: appendicitis; cosmetic fillers; had COVID.

Genetics

Carrier screening not done yet — OCA4/SLC45A2 status unknown until run.

Specialist read: fair, blonde and young, with the best egg-reserve number (AMH 7.63) of the un-screened girls and a very clean family history. The softer differences from Michelle are hazel eyes and Mediterranean/Brazilian ancestry.
4
Donor 4458Donor Nexus · ~30 · Scottish/Swedish/German + English/French · Florida
78Resembl.
Today
Athletic
Smiling
As a child

🔗 View Donor 4458 on Donor Nexus →

Physical

Height: 5’6″ · Weight: 125 lb · Eyes: Hazel · Hair: Brown, wavy · Complexion: Olive · Blood: O− · Hand: Right · athletic build.

Ancestry

Northern European — Scottish, Swedish, German (maternal) + English, French, German (paternal). A close ancestry match to Michelle’s English/Polish.

Education & work

B.A. Business Communication, cum laude (HS GPA 3.9); Client & Project Manager.

Personality (her words)

“I have a happy, charismatic personality and love connecting with people… At the same time, I’m an organized planner — my calendar is truly my pride and joy.”

Talents & interests

Very athletic — dance, basketball, horseback riding as a child; gym 5–6×/week, scuba diving, and she taught herself to ride a motorcycle and got her license. Draws and writes poetry.

Fertility

Exceptional proven fertility — multiple prior banking cycles with 22, 24, 24, 32, and 23 eggs retrieved (one cycle produced 9 chromosomally-normal embryos). A demonstrated high-responder. (No AMH listed, but the cycle results speak for themselves.)

Family (physical) & health

Parents and grandparents run tall with brown/blonde hair and blue/hazel eyes. Family health is essentially all “none” (no cancer, cardiac, diabetes, or mental-health history reported), aside from two grandparents’ age-85 deaths (pneumonia; heart failure). Her own: right-ankle surgery (2020).

Genetics

Screened — Horizon 275 · Carrier of DHCR7 (Smith-Lemli-Opitz). Not a carrier of SLC45A2/OCA4. DHCR7 doesn’t overlap Rob’s carrier gene — just confirm Rob’s panel was negative for DHCR7 (it should be; he was negative for everything except OCA4).

Specialist read: on results, she’s the strongest — a proven high-responder and the only one already screened (and clear on OCA4). On looks she’s fourth: olive skin and hazel eyes sit a step from Michelle’s fair, blue-eyed profile, though her Northern-European ancestry and athletic build match well.

Side by side

Michelle vs the Seven (newest first)

Scroll the table sideways to see every donor. 4742 is our matched donor; the rest are the bench.

DimensionMichelle4795 New4655 New4688 New47054742 (out)42854458
Overall resemblance—81807984838078
EyesBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueBlueHazelHazel
Natural hairLight brownBlondeBlonde, wavyBlondeBlondeBrownBlonde, wavyBrown, wavy
ComplexionFairLightFairFairFairFair / lightFairOlive
Face shapeLonger / ovalYouthful ovalFuller / rounderLong / ovalFuller / rounderOvalOval-ishOval
BuildLean, athletic, petiteAthletic, 5’6″Petite, 5’4″Lean, 5’9″Athletic, 5’6″Athletic, 5’4″5’5″, activeAthletic, 5’6″
Athletic spiritGymnastBasketballBoxing, surfTennis, padelYoga, boxing, skiFitness proRidingDance, gym, riding
AncestryEnglish + PolishCaucasian (unspec.)Danish/Italian/JewishTurkishPolish (both sides)EnglishItalian/PortugueseScottish/Swedish/English
Age—~18~26~27~25~31~26~30
Fertility signal—No AMH; unprovenProven (AMH TBD)AMH 2.88; proven 23 eggsAMH 5.61 (unproven)AMH 2.60; provenAMH 7.63Proven 22–32/cycle
Genetics—PendingPending (Jewish panel)Screened, OCA4-clearPendingIn screeningPendingScreened, OCA4-clear

Genetics

Cross-Match vs Rob

DonorCarrier panelCarriesOCA4 / SLC45A2Status
4705Not done yet—UnknownRun it
4742 ⛔Out · Aug 25—PendingIVFMD running now
4795Not done yet—UnknownRun it
4285Not done yet—UnknownRun it
4655Not done yet~20% Jewish — needs Ashkenazi panelUnknownRun expanded panel
4688Horizon 568SRNSNot a carrierOCA4-clear
4458Horizon 275DHCR7 (SLOS)Not a carrierOCA4-clear
Rob (reference)Invitae 556SLC45A2 onlyCarrier—

The one genetic box for any donor: is she also an OCA4 carrier? None here is known to be. For the three un-screened donors that answer comes from the panel IVFMD runs once you move on her; 4458 is already answered (no).

Do this next

To Move On One

  1. Pick who you want to pursue (closest look & heritage = 4705 or 4742; proven odds = 4458).
  2. Run / confirm her carrier screening through IVFMD and cross-match it to Rob — confirm she is not an OCA4 (SLC45A2) carrier (for 4458, confirm Rob is negative for DHCR7).
  3. Confirm the fresh-cycle timeline & cost with IVFMD (2–4+ months, higher cost than frozen); for 4742 ask them to weigh in on the AMH 2.60, and for 4705 note she is an unproven (first-time) donor.
  4. Request intro videos & expected egg numbers from the agency for your top pick.
  5. Log your pick on the Genetics match board as “screening pending.”
Prepared from each donor’s profile (photos are theirs, from those profiles). Resemblance is one input; carrier screening must be run/confirmed and cross-matched to Robert before any decision. Organizational research, not medical advice.

🕊   Our Little Miracle — the girls we’re considering.
Version 2.6 · updated Aug 22, 2026 · 1:23 PM ET